That's the debate going on at Dime Magazine right now.
Here's part of the argument for Ray:
He can still take over a game on the offensive end of the floor as the
go-to guy, but he can also come in and play a lesser role that forces
the defense to constantly be on the look-out, even if he’s having a
terrible shooting night. This isn’t to say that Redd doesn’t do the
same thing, but Allen is the guy I’d rather have in a plethora of game
situations.
And for Redd:
What separates one sniper from the other, though, is that long-range
bombs are the only consistently effective weapons left in Ray’s
arsenal, while Redd still roams every part of the court to inflict
damage.
Those are just part of each argument. Head on over and weigh in. I'm going to stay loyal to our guy, but you make up your own mind.
